There was someone else I was interested in so I couldn't give him a straightforward answer (when he told me he liked me).
I was interested in another guy so I couldn't give him a straight answer
「他に気になってる男性がいたから前向きな返事ができなかった」= There was someone else I was interested in so I couldn't give him a straightforward answer (when he told me he liked me). / I was interested in another guy so I couldn't give him a straight answer
ボキャブラリー
someone else, another guy = 他の人(男性)
interested in = 気になる(人)
couldn't = できなかった
give a straight(forward) answer = 前向きな返事をする
when he told me he liked me = 彼が告白した時